Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Next revision		Previous revision
financial_review_committee [2017/01/13 22:59] – created Carlos Pedrazafinancial_review_committee [2018/10/23 15:43] (current) – [Non-Disclosure Agreements] added tag Carlos Pedraza
Line 1: Line 1:
-====== Cinematographer Resigns from Axanar Independent Financial Review ======+<WRAP> 
 +{{::santiago-2.jpg|}} 
 +<wrap lo>Cinematographer Milton Santiago (right) on the upstate New York set of //Star Trek New Voyages//, where the //Axanar// short, "Heroes," was shot in November 2015.</wrap> <wrap lo><wrap lo>//Photo/Axanar Productions//</wrap></wrap> 
 +</WRAP> 
 + 
 +<WRAP> 
 +//**__<wrap em>Part 1</wrap>__**// 
 +</WRAP>
  
-//**Despite 'No Shenanigans,' Questions Arise from Review Process**//+====== What's Behind Resignation from Axanar Financial Review? ======
  
 +//**AxaMonitor Accused of Harassing Members of 'Independent' Committee**//
 +{{TOC}}
 <WRAP> <WRAP>
 //**__ __**// <wrap lo>**By [[user>cpedraza|Carlos Pedraza]]**</wrap> //**__ __**// <wrap lo>**By [[user>cpedraza|Carlos Pedraza]]**</wrap>
 </WRAP> </WRAP>
  
-Axanar cinematographer [[imdb>name/nm2010725/|Milton Santiago]] recused himself January 13, 2017, from the independent financial review committee tasked with examining the beleaguered production's books after the studios suing producer [[Alec Peters]] claimed he spent tens of thousands on personal expenses.+<wrap lo>Read Part 2: //[[financial_review_findings|Committee Reviews Only Part of Axanar's Finances]]//</wrap> 
 + 
 +Axanar cinematographer [[imdb>name/nm2010725/|Milton Santiago]] resigned January 13, 2017, from the independent financial review committee tasked with examining the beleaguered production's books after the studios suing producer [[Alec Peters]] claimed he spent tens of thousands on personal expenses.
  
 Peters had been [[summary_fact_check|under fire]] for weeks since court documents revealed his spending on such personal expenses as cellphone bills, restaurants, new tires and car maintenance, health insurance and gasoline for his girlfriend's car. Peters had been [[summary_fact_check|under fire]] for weeks since court documents revealed his spending on such personal expenses as cellphone bills, restaurants, new tires and car maintenance, health insurance and gasoline for his girlfriend's car.
 +
 +[{{ ::milton_santiago.jpg?direct|**Milton Santiago** <wrap lo><wrap lo>//Photo/Facebook//</wrap></wrap>}}]
  
 He appointed "an Independent Financial Review Committee, a group of industry professionals and donors, to review the financials and report back to the entire donor base."(([[http://www.axanarproductions.com/axanar-productions-statement-regarding-recent-motions-for-summary-judgement/|"Axanar Productions’ Statement Regarding Recent Motions for Summary Judgment," Axanar Productions website]], by Mike Bawden, 11/18/16.)) He appointed "an Independent Financial Review Committee, a group of industry professionals and donors, to review the financials and report back to the entire donor base."(([[http://www.axanarproductions.com/axanar-productions-statement-regarding-recent-motions-for-summary-judgement/|"Axanar Productions’ Statement Regarding Recent Motions for Summary Judgment," Axanar Productions website]], by Mike Bawden, 11/18/16.))
  
-**AxaMonitor** learned who the committee members were and obtained comments from all three, raising new questions about Axanar's financials and its avowed transparency. Peters' messages were provided by a source only by under condition of anonymity. +**AxaMonitor** learned who the committee members were and obtained comments from all three, raising new questions about Axanar's financials and its avowed transparency. Peters' messages were provided by a source who made them available only under condition of anonymity.
- +
-[{{ ::milton_santiago.jpg?direct&100|**Milton Santiago** <wrap lo><wrap lo>//Photo/Facebook//</wrap></wrap>}}]+
  
 +<wrap lo>Read //[[milton statement|Milton Santiago's full statement explaining his resignation from Axanar's independent financial review committee]]//</wrap>
 ===== Independent Reviewers? ===== ===== Independent Reviewers? =====
  
-Peters had touted the independence and expertise of the committee members, whom he had refused to publicly name until he learned **AxaMonitor** had communicated with all three earlier in the week. All three were closer to Axanar than the term independent generally implies:+Peters had touted the independence and expertise of the committee members, whom he had refused to publicly name until he learned **AxaMonitor** had communicated with all three earlier in the week:
   * Santiago was director of photography on Peters' short film, //Prelude to Axanar//, and was slated to fill the role in the feature-length followup, //Axanar//. <WRAP right round important 50%>[{{ ::kevin-rubio.jpg?direct&100|**Kevin Rubio** <wrap lo><wrap lo>//Photo/LinkedIn//</wrap></wrap>}}]   * Santiago was director of photography on Peters' short film, //Prelude to Axanar//, and was slated to fill the role in the feature-length followup, //Axanar//. <WRAP right round important 50%>[{{ ::kevin-rubio.jpg?direct&100|**Kevin Rubio** <wrap lo><wrap lo>//Photo/LinkedIn//</wrap></wrap>}}]
 <wrap lo><wrap em>DISCLOSURE</wrap> Rubio and **AxaMonitor**'s Carlos Pedraza collaborated for a short time on the //Star Trek New Voyages// episode, "Enemy Starfleet," shot in 2008. Rubio resigned as director of the episode; Pedraza was first assistant director.</wrap> <wrap lo><wrap em>DISCLOSURE</wrap> Rubio and **AxaMonitor**'s Carlos Pedraza collaborated for a short time on the //Star Trek New Voyages// episode, "Enemy Starfleet," shot in 2008. Rubio resigned as director of the episode; Pedraza was first assistant director.</wrap>
 </WRAP> </WRAP>
   * Writer-producer [[imdb>name/nm0748352/|Kevin Rubio]] was a vocal defender of Axanar. He is well known for his 1997 Star Wars parody fan film, [[imdb>title/tt0153301/|TROOPS]]. He went on to a career including credits such as //Star Wars: The Clone Wars//, //Ben 10: Omniverse// and //Power Rangers: Samurai//.   * Writer-producer [[imdb>name/nm0748352/|Kevin Rubio]] was a vocal defender of Axanar. He is well known for his 1997 Star Wars parody fan film, [[imdb>title/tt0153301/|TROOPS]]. He went on to a career including credits such as //Star Wars: The Clone Wars//, //Ben 10: Omniverse// and //Power Rangers: Samurai//.
-  * New York-based financial services professional and Broadway producer Cedric Yau, who donated $10,000 directly to Axanar, an amount not included in the funds raised via [[axanar_kickstarter_details|Kickstarter]] and [[axanar_indiegogo_details|Indiegogo]]. +  * Axanar associate producer, New York-based financial services professional and Broadway producer Cedric Yau (//Godspell//), who donated $10,000 directly to Axanar, an amount not included in the funds raised via [[axanar_kickstarter_details|Kickstarter]] and [[axanar_indiegogo_details|Indiegogo]].
- +
-==== Non-Disclosure Agreements ====+
  
 [{{ ::cedric-yau.jpg?direct&100|**Cedric Yau** <wrap lo><wrap lo>//Photo/LinkedIn//</wrap></wrap>}}] [{{ ::cedric-yau.jpg?direct&100|**Cedric Yau** <wrap lo><wrap lo>//Photo/LinkedIn//</wrap></wrap>}}]
  
-All three members of the committee responded to **AxaMonitor**'s interview requests under the constraints of non-disclosure agreements they had signed with regard to Axanar's finances.+==== Defining Independence ====
  
-===== Review Committee Setup =====+When confronted with skepticism that a committee comprised of Axanar supporters may not truly be viewed as independent, Peters replied through his surrogate, Jonathan Lane:
  
-The formation of the committee was announced on Axanar's website on November 18, 2015. +> “Independent” means they are not employees. And since we have no employees, these people are independent. A review committed for any Fortune 500 company has PAID board members do this work. And you have an “Axanar Team Member” because he knows what went on and provides critical insight.(([[http://fanfilmfactor.com/2017/01/13/alec-peters-discusses-axanars-financials-and-his-review-committee-interview/#comment-4362|Alec Peters comment]] on "Alec Peters Discusses Axanar's Financials and his Review Committee! (Interview)," Fan Film Factor blog, 1/13/17.))
  
 +In a phone interview, **AxaMonitor** asked Santiago if he was satisfied that the status of the committee was truly independent. He pointed to a statement Rubio provided:
  
-===== 'No Shenanigans' =====+> We truly are independent, and Ares Studio [Axanar] has complied with all our requests. … I do not wish there to be an appearance of impropriety or bias one way or the other.((Facebook private message from Kevin Rubio to **AxaMonitor** writer Carlos Pedraza, 1/11/17.))
  
-Peters went on to describe Santiago's as "[Axanar's] amazing director of photography, [who] was to be the third on the committee," indicating Santiago had recused himself prior to the committee commencing work.+Santiago stated, "I affirm what Kevin said," and the interview concluded. 
  
-In fact, in private messages obtained by **AxaMonitor**, Peters described the committee's work as nearly done when he was pressed for a date when the committee's report would be released.+==== Resignation ====
  
-<WRAP center box 90%> +Several minutes after Santiago's first phone interview, he called back to announce he planned to resign from the committee. He would not provide an explanation. But the following day, Peters described Santiago's reason for recusing himself: 
-<wrap lo>**Alec Peters**: I said next week. \\ + 
-[**Redacted**]: An actual date, though? \\ +> Milton has backed out for a couple of reasons.  First, he really doesn’t feel qualified to judge the financials as that is outside his wheelhouse. … The fact that he wants the donors to feel like the committee is qualified to do the work, even when no one would question his expertise, is a credit to him.(([[http://fanfilmfactor.com/2017/01/13/alec-peters-discusses-axanars-financials-and-his-review-committee-interview/|"Alec Peters Discusses Axanar's Financials and his Review Committee! (Interview)]]," Fan Film Factor blog 1/13/17.)) 
-**Peters**: I don't know. Is that so hard to understand? Seriously. I said next week. Fucking relax.</wrap>+ 
 +Peters went on to describe Santiago as "[Axanar's] amazing director of photography, [who] was to be the third on the committee," indicating Santiago had recused himself prior to the committee commencing work, while simultaneously indicating it was nearly complete, with a report due the following week.(([[http://fanfilmfactor.com/2017/01/13/alec-peters-discusses-axanars-financials-and-his-review-committee-interview/|Jonathan Lane, "Alec Peters Discusses Axanar's Financials and his Review Committee! (Interview)]]," Fan Film Factor blog 1/13/17.)) 
 + 
 +=== AxaMonitor 'Harassment' === 
 + 
 +When Peters announced Santiago's resignation on his surrogate's blog, Fan Film Factor, he also attributed his cinematographer's decision to alleged harassment by **AxaMonitor**'s Pedraza. "He doesn’t want to subject himself or his family to that," Peters said. 
 + 
 +Peters used harassment as the excuse for not releasing the name of the "long-term Axanar team member" who would replace Santiago. "Pedraza has been harassing the members of the committee to get information, and we don’t want any other committee member to be subject to this treatment. … He’s called all three personally multiple times."(([[http://fanfilmfactor.com/2017/01/13/alec-peters-discusses-axanars-financials-and-his-review-committee-interview/|Jonathan Lane, "Alec Peters Discusses Axanar's Financials and his Review Committee! (Interview)]]," Fan Film Factor blog 1/13/17.)) 
 + 
 +The so-called harassment of Santiago and Rubio consisted of a Facebook private message asking if they would consent to be interviewed; Yau was contacted by email. 
 + 
 +=== Responding to Harassment === 
 + 
 +In reply, Rubio issued a short and courteous statement. Santiago phoned and conversed for 55 minutes. Yau called and spoke with **AxaMonitor** for nearly an hour. The "multiple" phone calls consisted of Pedraza and Yau calling one another back when their cell phone call dropped several times over the course of the interview. 
 + 
 +==== Non-Disclosure Agreements ==== 
 + 
 +All three members of the committee responded to **AxaMonitor**'s interview requests under the constraints of non-disclosure agreements they had signed with regard to Axanar's finances. {{:axamonitor-ico.gif?nolink|}} 
 + 
 +---- 
 + 
 +<WRAP centeralign> 
 +<wrap lo>**Next** » Part 2: //[[financial_review_findings|Committee Reviews Only Part of Axanar's Finances]]//</wrap>
 </WRAP> </WRAP>
 +
 +----
 +**Keywords** {{tag>commercial financials}}